Selling a rental property

Selling a rental with tenants in place

You can sell a rented home without waiting for it to be empty, and without making life miserable for a good tenant. Which way is best depends on the lease, the rent and who is likely to buy it.

  • Sell to an investor with the lease and the tenant in place
  • Or time the sale for when the lease ends
  • Showings arranged with notice and respect for your tenant
  • A value both ways: as a rental and as an empty home

4.9★ from 73 client reviewsLicensed Florida Broker Associate23 years in North Florida

Free · no obligation

See what your rental would sell for

Or call or text (386) 627-3612. You talk to me, not a call center.

How it goes

Four steps, one at a time

1. Read the lease

A lease with months left stays with the house, and the buyer becomes the landlord. A month-to-month tenancy gives you more choices.

2. Price it both ways

An investor pays for the income. A family buying a home to live in pays for the house. I'll show you what each kind of buyer would likely pay.

3. Bring the tenant along

A tenant who knows what is happening keeps the place tidy and lets buyers in. I talk to them first, give proper notice and keep showings to a schedule.

4. Close and hand over

At closing the security deposit and the prorated rent go to the buyer, and the tenant is told in writing where to pay from then on.

What happens to the lease when you sell?

It carries over. A buyer takes the home subject to the lease and has to honor it until it ends, so a tenant with eight months left can stay for those eight months. That suits an investor, who gets income from the first day. It does not suit a buyer who wants to move in next month.

If the tenancy is month to month, Florida law lets either side end it with at least 30 days' written notice before the end of a monthly period. Whether to do that before you list is a judgment call: an empty home shows better and appeals to more buyers, but you give up the rent while it sells.

Showing a home someone lives in

Florida law allows an owner to show a rented home to buyers, and a tenant can't unreasonably refuse. I give tenants at least 24 hours' notice, group showings into set windows and ask before taking photos. Some owners offer a small rent credit for keeping the home ready to show, which often pays for itself.

Selling to an investor, or for cash

The simplest sale of a rented home is to another landlord. They want to see the lease, the rent history and what you spend on the property, and many pay cash, so there is no appraisal and the tenant barely notices the change. I work with local investors who buy rentals in Palm Coast, Flagler Beach and Bunnell. See how the cash offer works.

Taxes to ask your CPA about

A rental is taxed differently from a home you live in. The depreciation you have claimed over the years is generally taxed when you sell, and the exclusion for a main home usually does not apply. Some owners defer the tax by buying another investment property through a like-kind exchange, which has to be set up before closing. Talk to your CPA before the home goes on the market.

This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Your attorney and CPA can tell you how the rules apply to you.

My promise to sellers

The Easy-Exit Listing Guarantee

List your home with me and you're never locked in. If you're unhappy with my service for any reason, you can cancel the listing any time before you accept an offer. No cancellation fee, and no bill for the photos or the marketing.

Read the full terms

David Stanley · Closed sales since January 2022 · Stellar MLS, updated daily

98%
Median sale-to-list price
27
Median days to contract
169
Closed sales
4.9★
73 client reviews

Free tools

Get your numbers first

What's it worth?

Your home's value in about a minute, from recent sales near you.

Get my value

What would you walk away with?

Your price minus commission, payoff and Flagler County closing costs, line by line.

Run the net sheet

Need it sold fast, as-is?

Cash offers from local buyers, with the list-it number next to them.

Get a cash offer

Rather talk it through?

Pick a time for a free, private consultation by phone, video or at the house.

Book a consultation

Questions I Hear Most

Can I sell my rental while the tenant has a lease?
Yes. The buyer takes the home subject to the lease and becomes the tenant's new landlord.
Do I have to tell my tenant I'm selling?
You should, and it works out better when you do. You will need their cooperation for photos and showings, and Florida law requires reasonable notice before you enter.
How much notice do I have to give a month-to-month tenant in Florida?
At least 30 days' written notice before the end of a monthly period, under Florida Statutes 83.57.
What happens to the security deposit?
It transfers to the buyer at closing, usually as a credit on the settlement statement, and the tenant is told in writing who holds it.
Will a tenant-occupied home sell for less?
It can, if the rent is under the market or the home is hard to show. A well-kept rental with a good tenant and market rent can sell quickly to an investor. I'll show you both values before you decide.

Sources

See what your rental would sell for

I'll send two numbers: what an investor would pay with the tenant in place, and what the home would bring empty.

Other situations: Inherited a home · Selling during a divorce · Relocating out of the area · Downsizing